11 high school lacrosse players suspected in hazing of teammate in Syracuse turn themselves in, avoiding kidnapping charges

By Holly Yan and Emma Tucker, CNN

(CNN) — All 11 Westhill High School lacrosse players suspected of being involved in hazing a teammate have turned themselves in, Onondaga County First Chief Assistant District Attorney Joseph Coolican said Wednesday.

The non-juvenile students will be arraigned, while the juveniles will go “straight to family court,” Coolican said. They face misdemeanor charges of unlawful imprisonment, District Attorney William Fitzpatrick said.

The Westhill High School student athletes – who are not being identified due to their age – are accused of victimizing five younger players in an incident that goes “way beyond hazing,” Fitzpatrick said Tuesday.

Fitzpatrick made a one-time, public offer to the suspects on Tuesday: Turn yourself in to the sheriff’s department within 48 hours, and you can face a less serious misdemeanor charge of unlawful imprisonment. The suspects surrendered on Tuesday and Wednesday, within a day of the district attorney’s hard deadline, Fitzpatrick said.

Most of the suspects are minors, but at least one is over the age of 18, according to Coolican.

Here’s what we know about the case that has stunned the community:

What happened?

Some of the suspects tricked the younger players into believing they were going to McDonald’s after a lacrosse game last Thursday, Fitzpatrick said.

The driver of the vehicle then claimed he was lost in a remote part of the county. There, “accomplices jumped out of the woods, pretending to be kidnappers,” the district attorney said.

The accomplices were dressed in black, wielding what appeared to be at least one handgun and at least one knife, the DA said.

“Some of the (victims) were able to escape,” Fitzpatrick said. But one of the students couldn’t flee.

The group put a pillowcase over that student’s head, tied him up and threw him in the trunk of a car before ditching him in another wooded part of the county, Fitzpatrick said.

The younger player was eventually returned home. But “there was a period of time where he thought he was going to be abandoned in the middle of nowhere,” the DA said.

“I’ve seen the videotape of what happened to this young man,” Fitzpatrick said. “It is not a rite of passage. It is not a trivial matter. I don’t know how long this young man will be affected by what happened to him.”

The video also captured reactions from some of the suspects, Fitzpatrick said. “You can hear that some of the individuals found it amusing.”

Why did the suspects avoid kidnapping charges?

At the news briefing on Tuesday, before all suspects surrendered, the district attorney raised the prospect of the more serious charge of kidnapping.

“If you don’t — if you’re tougher than me, you’re a gambler and you’re going to play the odds, you don’t think you’re going to get caught — trust me, the men and women of the Onondaga County Sheriff’s Department are going to identify you,” Fitzpatrick said.

If the suspects chose not to turn themselves in, they would be arrested, prosecuted as adults, and charged with felony kidnapping, “perhaps in the second degree,” Fitzpatrick warned on Tuesday.

The suspects under 18 who turned themselves in will be sent to family court and will not be subject to penal law, Coolican said.

“If they’re 18, they would be eligible for something called Youthful Offender status, which would seal the record in New York state,” the assistant district attorney said earlier on Wednesday.

“If they turn themselves in and (are) charged with the misdemeanor, they would not have any permanent record,” Coolican added.

As for the apparent gun used in the incident, Fitzpatrick did not say whether it was real or fake. But “we’re not going to charge anybody with possession of a weapon,” he said.

What happens next?

The rest of the varsity boys’ lacrosse season has been canceled, Westhill Central School District Superintendent Stephen Dunham said Tuesday.

While most of the team was not involved in the incident or knew about the plans in advance, “We must address the culture of the program, and the most appropriate way to do that is with a reset,” the superintendent said.

The school district has launched its own investigation, though it “cannot comment or share specific details about student discipline,” Dunham said.

But he noted Westhill Central School District’s policy “strictly prohibits” hazing “in all forms.”

“Hazing is an indefensible act,” the superintendent said. “ It can be humiliating and degrading, potentially causing physical and emotional harm.”

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2025 Cable News Network, Inc., a Warner Bros. Discovery Company. All rights reserved.