CNN

Kilmar Abrego Garcia has been released from criminal custody, 5 months after he was unlawfully deported

By CNN

Published August 22, 2025 3:20 pm

CNN

By Devan Cole, CNN

(CNN) — Kilmar Abrego Garcia was released from criminal custody in Tennessee on Friday, the latest development in a dramatic legal saga surrounding the wrongly deported Maryland father of three.

This marks the first time he has not been imprisoned since the Trump administration deported him to a notorious mega-prison in El Salvador in March and later brought him back to the US to face human smuggling charges.

Since being returned to the US in June to face the pair of federal charges, Abrego Garcia has been behind bars in Tennessee, where he successfully convinced two federal judges to order his release while he awaits trial.

But even as Abrego Garcia walked out of a jail in Tennessee Friday afternoon to make his way back to Maryland, where he was living and working before the Trump administration wrongfully deported him in mid-March, his immediate fate in the US remained uncertain.

Administration officials have wavered this summer on whether they would deport him before his criminal trial is scheduled to begin in January. That equivocation prompted a federal judge in Maryland to set up guardrails last month to ensure Abrego Garcia isn’t hastily removed from the US again.

“Today, Kilmar Abrego Garcia is free. He is presently en route to his family in Maryland, after being unlawfully arrested and deported, and then imprisoned, all because of the government’s vindictive attack on a man who had the courage to fight back against the administration’s continuing assault on the rule of law,” Sean Hecker, one of Abrego Garcia’s attorneys, said in a statement.

“He is grateful that his access to American courts has provided meaningful due process,” Hecker added.

Prosecutors did not show that Abrego Garcia is a ‘danger’ to others

Federal prosecutors mounted a weekslong effort this summer to keep Abrego Garcia behind bars pending his trial on the pair of human smuggling charges.

They sought to paint him as a dangerous criminal whose alleged crimes and personal history warranted detention while his case unfolded. But both a magistrate judge in Nashville and the federal judge overseeing his trial resoundingly rejected those arguments.

“The government’s general statements about the crimes brought against Abrego, and the evidence it has in support of those crimes, do not prove Abrego’s dangerousness,” US District Judge Waverly Crenshaw wrote in a 37-page ruling last month as he rebuffed a request from prosecutors to reverse a similar ruling from the magistrate judge.

Just after Crenshaw issued his ruling, the magistrate judge – Barbara Holmes – said in another decision that Abrego Garcia would remain behind bars for at least 30 more days, granting an unopposed request by his lawyers for him to stay in criminal custody. Abrego Garcia’s lawyers had made the request in an effort to ensure hasty deportation proceedings wouldn’t begin once he’s released from custody.

Guardrails around a second deportation

The same day Crenshaw issued his ruling, the federal judge in Maryland who ordered the Trump administration to “facilitate” Abrego Garcia’s return from a mega-prison in El Salvador issued her own ruling that set up guardrails intended to prevent officials from deporting him again with little regard for his due process rights.

Under the order issued last month by US District Judge Paula Xinis, officials are barred from immediately taking Abrego Garcia into US Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody. They must also restore him to the legal position he was in prior to his deportation earlier this year.

That includes putting him under supervision by the ICE Baltimore Field Office. That supervision allowed him to work and live in Maryland, with occasional check-ins with an immigration officer.

How and whether Xinis’ decision is complied with will be closely watched in coming days.

Importantly, the ruling doesn’t prevent officials from deporting him again, including to a country other than El Salvador.

“Once Abrego Garcia is restored under the ICE Supervision Order out of the Baltimore Field Office, Defendants may take whatever action is available to them under the law,” the judge wrote. “So long as such actions are taken within the bounds of the Constitution and applicable statutes, this Court will have nothing further to say.”

Abrego Garcia’s attorneys acknowledged that reality as he was released from jail on Friday, saying in a statement that “he is far from safe.”

“ICE detention or deportation to an unknown third country still threaten to tear his family apart. A measure of justice has been done, but the government must stop pursuing actions that would once again separate this family,” his lawyer, Simon Sandoval-Moshenberg, said in a statement.

Human smuggling case

Until early June, Abrego Garcia was in El Salvador, where he had spent time in the country’s notorious Cecot mega-prison. US officials deported him there in violation of a 2019 order from a judge that said he could not be deported to his home country because of fears that he would face gang violence.

The administration spent months fighting directives from judges to work to bring him back stateside, but ultimately returned him to the US in June to face the two human smuggling charges.

Federal prosecutors accused Abrego Garcia and others of partaking in a conspiracy in recent years in which they “knowingly and unlawfully transported thousands of undocumented aliens who had no authorization to be present in the United States, and many of whom were MS-13 members and associates.”

Abrego Garcia and his family say he fled gang violence in El Salvador and have denied allegations he’s associated with MS-13.

Earlier this week, Abrego Garcia mounted a bid to have the case thrown out based on his assertion that he’s the subject of “vindictive and selective prosecution” as punishment for his decision to challenge his wrongful deportation.

In court papers, his attorneys pointed to statements made by various administration officials – from President Donald Trump to Attorney General Pam Bondi – to make the case that his prosecution is intended to justify “officials’ false claims that deporting him to El Salvador had been the right thing to do.”

Such requests, they acknowledged, “are infrequently made and rarely succeed. But if there has ever been a case for dismissal on those grounds, this is that case.”

Crenshaw has asked for a response early next month.

This story and headline have been updated with Abrego Garcia’s release.